The London Criminal Courts Solicitors' Association

Rochdale grooming trial: how the case unfolded

 
latest news for 24 May 2013
Search by Category:
Search by Sub Category:
Search by Keyword

Show All » In the Media » General »
Rochdale grooming trial: how the case unfolded - June-21-12
Source: The Telegraph (Nigel Bunyan)

But after being taken to an interview room by Greater Manchester Police officers, she spent six hours pouring out the horrifying reason for her rage: she had been raped repeatedly by a gang of men, she said, who would ply her with vodka and threaten violence if she did not submit to them.

Shabir Ahmed, 59, who can only now be named after being convicted for a series of other attacks and Kabeer Hassan, 25, were both arrested and questioned, but for reasons that are now the subject of an independent inquiry, no prosecutions were brought.

It meant the 15-year-old, known as Girl A, and scores of others continued to suffer at the hands of a nine-strong paedophile gang of Asian men who preyed on vulnerable white girls they saw as "easy meat".

By the time police finally caught up with them, they had abused 47 girls, according to the police, though the true total is likely to be far higher.

It has left the force, prosecutors and social workers facing uncomfortable questions about whether they failed to act for fear of being accused of racism.

Girl A's unimaginable ordeal began in July 2008 when she was taken to one of two takeaways used by the gang, the Balti House and Tasty Bites, which are both now under new ownership.

Another white teenaged girl, nicknamed The Honey Monster, had turned from victim to abuser and was used by the gang to find them a steady supply of vulnerable youngsters like Girl A, who was living in the same house as her at the time after becoming estranged from her parents.

Girl A had been to the takeaway with The Honey Monster before, and had been given free food, cigarettes, alcohol and taxi rides home.

"It made me feel like I was pretty," she later said. But it was all part of the grooming process by the paedophile gang, and on this occasion she was given vodka until she was "dead drunk" and then invited upstairs by Ahmed, the ringleader of the gang.

"He started talking about all the things he'd bought for me, and how he wanted something back for it," said Girl A, who looked even younger than her 15 years because of her flat chest and petite frame.

"It's part of the deal," he told her. "I bought you vodka, you have to give me something."

She tried to spurn his advances, but he pushed her onto a bare mattress and raped her. As she sobbed afterwards, he said: "Don't cry, I love you."

It was around three weeks later that Girl A was arrested and alerted police to her ordeal, leading to the arrests of Hassan and Ahmed.

Rochdale social services were alerted to her allegations, yet nothing was done to protect her, even though police insist to this day they believed her story.

Yet it took them 11 months to send a file on the case to the Crown Prosecution Service, which decided in July 2009 that Girl A would not be a credible witness in court and did not, therefore, go ahead with a prosecution. The police decided not to contest the decision even though Ahmed had no explanation for how his DNA had been found on Girl A's underwear.

As a result, the worst of Girl A's ordeal came after she had told police what was going on. In the four months after she spoke to police, she was driven around a succession of sordid flats and houses where she would be raped by up to five men each night, four or five days each week.

The only affect the arrests had on the pattern of abuse was that she was passed to the control of Abdul Aziz, 41, a taxi driver who would transport her between the "chill" houses where she would be raped.

Many of her abusers are unlikely ever to be identified, but among them was Kabeer Hassan, to whom she was passed on as "a treat".

The threat of violence was ever-present if she considered trying to escape.

Meanwhile Honey Monster was busily at work finding a steady supply of other girls for the gang to rape, in return for a finder's fee of up to £200 per girl.

One of the abusers, Abdul Rauf, 43, once told her not to take a "little" girl because she was too young, but Honey Monster ignored him, saying another girl had moved away and "the men wanted new girls".

She would later escape prosecution because she, too, had been abused and was seen as a victim who had lost all sense of right and wrong.

The gang also included Mohammed Sajid, 35, Adil Khan, 42, Abdul Quayyum, 43, Mohammed Amin, 44, all but one of whom are taxi drivers of Pakistani origin, and Hamid Safi, an Afghan asylum seeker. They were convicted of charges involving five girls in total.

Among them was Girl E, who had only just turned 13 when Sajid picked her up in his taxi and plied her with vodka before raping her. She later said Sajid and his co-defendants "treat white girls as easy meat".

Another victim, Girl C, became pregnant at 13 by Adil Khan. She said: "Pakistani men pass you round like a ball, they're all in a massive circle and put a white girl in the middle."

When a victim called Girl B was being raped by one of the defendants, Safi interrupted, saying: "I want a turn, I want a turn." Girl B saw him cutting his own arm with a razor blade before he threatened her with it to make her comply. She said: "I'd rather that happen than get my throat slit."

The gang's victims were typically in care or on "at risk" registers, their isolation from their families having turned them to drink, drugs or both.

One of the men on trial in Liverpool said: "You white people train them in sex and drinking, so when they come to us they are fully trained."

Others have told their victims it is fine to sleep with them "because it's what we do in our country".

Girl A finally escaped the gang in December 2008 when teachers noticed how often Asian men were picking her up from school. By then she was pregnant, and social workers said her baby would be taken away at birth if she did not move away from The Honey Monster, so she went back to her parents' home and eventually moved out of the area altogether.

"What they did to me was evil," she said. "They ripped away all my dignity and all my last bit of self-esteem. By the end of it I had no emotion whatsoever."

But it took another two years for the authorities to catch up with the gang. Rochdale's Crisis Intervention Team, an NHS clinic offering advice on abortions and sexual health to vulnerable young women, alerted police after a number of girls came to them with similar stories about being groomed for sex by Asian men.

A wave of arrests followed in December 2010, including Ahmed and Kabeer Hassan, the men who had escaped trial in 2008 because prosecutors did not think a jury would believe Girl A. Yesterday Girl A finally had the satisfaction of seeing the gang convicted after a jury had no difficulty in believing her story, and those of her fellow victims.

Related Documents:
The Telegraph http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/crime/9347305/Rochdale-grooming-trial-how-the-case-unfolded.html

« Go Back


Other In the Media General news

In the Media
General
May-23-13 - Squatting in commercial premises » The Government seems to have realised there is no distinction between squatting in residential and commercial premises ... [view]
May-23-13 - Can’t find a contract? Become a paralegal » “Paralegal” is becoming a career in its own right and is no longer seen as the professional cul-de-sac that it once was ... [view]
May-23-13 - Salaries for new solicitors ‘too high’ » Although some London firms pay their newly qualified solicitors up to £95,000, the age of high salaries could be about to end ... [view]
May-23-13 - Closure threat to 150 High Street law firms » Is the solicitors’ regulator putting English firms at risk by spending too much time on rules and form-filling? ... [view]
May-23-13 - Be a judicial assistant for a year » Each year seven new judicial assistants work with Supreme Court judges in an “unparalled learning opportunity” ... [view]
May-23-13 - Abuse trial that shamed the British legal system » Demands for vulnerable witnesses to receive greater protection in child sex cases are made today as the full details of a trial that critics say shamed British justice can finally be revealed. ... [view]
May-23-13 - Disability test ‘unfair’ to the mentally ill, judges rule » The Government’s controversial medical test to assess whether disabled people are fit for work has been judged unfair on the mentally ill by a court which has ordered sweeping changes. ... [view]
May-22-13 - Naming suspects is a powerful tool for justice, warns DPP » The Director of Public Prosecutions said yesterday that a ban on naming people who have been arrested could harm justice. ... [view]
May-22-13 - British computer hackers behind bars - from the archive, 22 May 1993 » Yesterday, two bright young men described by a judge as having indulged in 'intellectual joyriding ' were jailed for six months. ... [view]
May-22-13 - Small business spurning legal services – LSB research » Wednesday 22 May 2013 by John Hyde Just one in eight small businesses will turn to a solicitor to solve a legal problem despite many suffering financial loss as a result. ... [view]
May-22-13 - HMRC proposes crackdown on LLP ‘disguised employment’ » Wednesday 22 May 2013 by Michael Cross Some members of limited liability partnership (LLP) firms could face higher tax and national insurance deductions under government proposals for tackling 'disguised employment' published this week. ... [view]
May-22-13 - Banned driver who mowed down cyclists is jailed for 10 years » A disqualified driver fleeing police was jailed for 10 years and six months on Wednesday for killing a couple he mowed down in a car as they rode their tandem bike. ... [view]
May-22-13 - Man jailed for smothering mother » A man who smothered and strangled his mother has been jailed for 13 years, police said today. ... [view]
May-22-13 - MPs raise new concerns about police commissioner spending » The House of Commons' Home Affairs Select Committee found 17 commissioners, or PCCs, had a budget higher than the former police authorities, which were disbanded when the new directly-elected positions were created last November. ... [view]
May-22-13 - Is Interpol fighting for truth and justice, or helping the villains? » Most of us take an entirely positive view of Interpol, the cross-border crime-busting organisation, even though we have only the haziest view of what it actually does. This is at least partly thanks to the influence of Biggles, hero of schoolboy fiction, who used to go on perilous missions for Interpol to track down international felons. Agatha Christie was another powerful influence. Her Belgian detective Hercule Poirot might have a discrete word with well-placed Interpol friends when he wanted information on some master criminal. ... [view]
May-21-13 - Family of woman killed by convicted murderer call for public inquiry » Maria Stubbings, 50, was murdered by Marc Chivers at her home in Chelmsford, Essex, after he had been freed from a German prison less than a year earlier, having served 15 years for murdering his then girlfriend Sabine Rappold. ... [view]
May-21-13 - ACPO comment on the national police response to domestic abuse » ACPO lead on domestic abuse Chief Constable Carmel Napier said: ... [view]
May-21-13 - Twitter hit-and-run boast shows dangers of 'road tax' entitlement | Dawn Foster » It's safe to assume that most people in the event of hitting a cyclist while driving, who realised what they had done, would stop, call the police, and stay on the scene. Not so for one young woman, who appears to have hit a cyclist, carried on driving, and then most bizarrely taken to Twitter to boast of the incident. ... [view]
May-21-13 - Call for police to be allowed to name some suspects on arrest » Britain's top prosecutor has called for more "wriggle room" in new rules which say police should not normally name suspects they have arrested before they are charged unless there are exceptional circumstances. ... [view]
May-21-13 - Poor will suffer from court fee changes, MoJ warned » Tuesday 21 May 2013 by John Hyde Government plans to means-test waivers for civil court or tribunal fees could impact the most deprived and vulnerable sections of society, the Civil Justice Council has warned. ... [view]
May-21-13 - Hospital ward for UK's most dangerous killers run like 'social club' » While staff at the all-male Broadmoor top security hospital watched television, at least one patient was enjoying a sexual relationship with a woman therapist, it was claimed on Tuesday, leading to another offender asking to be given an HIV test. ... [view]
May-21-13 - New doubt cast on police 'secret arrests' » Keir Starmer QC, the head of the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS), told MPs he would like "wriggle room" to name suspects before they are charged. ... [view]
May-21-13 - Police hunt prison fugitive after string of robberies » Police are hunting for a fugitive who has absconded from prison and carried out a string of robberies. ... [view]
May-21-13 - Crime commissioner pledges to appoint teenage crime tsar » The post will be created in Staffordshire later this year, and Matthew Ellis aims to employ someone under-18 as he believes that they can better connect with their peers. ... [view]
May-21-13 - Thousands of child sex abuse victims, says minister » Lord Taylor of Holbeach said the figure - which he described as "dramatic" - hinted at the true scale of organised sex abuse in Britain. ... [view]
May-20-13 - High-value cases take toll on fraud-busting numbers at the SFO » Britain’s fraud-fighting agency prosecuted only 20 defendants over the past year, compared with 52 the year before, new figures have revealed. ... [view]
May-20-13 - Police retain DNA from thousands of children »  ... [view]
May-20-13 - Police take DNA samples from children every ten minutes » In total over the last two years police have taken DNA samples from 120,000 children. In 2012 officers took nearly 54,000 samples from people under 18, including more than 360 from ten-year-olds. ... [view]
May-20-13 - Teenage burglar with electronic tag pulls a fast one on G4S security official » The teenager was asked over the phone by an official from G4S to walk around the perimeter of his home so they could map the curfew zone they had to monitor. ... [view]
May-20-13 - Nick Clegg: Prison costs more than going to Eton » The Liberal Democrat leader gave a speech outlining support for probation staff who start their own John Lewis-style mutuals, and announced a £7 million package to help the fledgling mutuals and small rehabilitation charities bid for contracts. ... [view]
May-20-13 - Thousands of British police sent to Northern Ireland amid fear of terror attack at G8 summit » World leaders including Barack Obama and Vladimir Putin will jet into the luxury Loch Erne Golf Resort in County Fermanagh for the two day conference which has in the past attracted wide scale demonstrations and public disorder. ... [view]
May-20-13 - Retired priest jailed over sex attacks at children's home » A retired Church of England priest found guilty of a catalogue of historic sex attacks on children at a Barnardo's home has been jailed for 10 years. ... [view]
May-20-13 - New plans for secret arrests introduced » New guidance rubber stamped by the College of Policing yesterday, will now mean forces can only identify suspects before they are charged in exceptional circumstances. ... [view]
May-19-13 - Plebgate: Mitchell supporters demand answers about Met Commissioner's role » Friends of the former chief whip, who was forced to resign after admitting swearing at police officers in Downing Street, have established that the head of the Metropolitan Police held a meeting with journalists just prior to reports appearing in two newspapers suggesting a police investigation had found no evidence to support Mr Mitchell's version of events. ... [view]
May-19-13 - New Asbo laws could infringe freedom, think tank warns » Fresh powers contained in the Anti-Social Behaviour, Crime and Policing Bill, which was announced in the Queen's Speech, will give local authorities the right to outlaw certain activities from designated areas. ... [view]
May-18-13 - Royal Academy of Music's former IT head jailed for conning school out of £370,000 » Steven Newell, 32, used false qualifications to get the job before stealing the money, which he spent on 'gambling, drinking and women'. ... [view]
May-18-13 - What do you do after a burglary? » There has been good news on burglary in recent weeks. Official figures show that break-ins were down 9% in 2012, in part because the fall in electrical prices means there's less stuff that is worth nicking. The Economist last week analysed the "Not so mean streets" of Britain where despite recession and high unemployment, burglary continues its decade-long decline. But this offered little comfort to us after arriving home from the cinema last weekend to find our home ransacked. Computers stolen, watches and jewellery gone, cameras looted, drawers emptied and clothes strewn across the floor. Nothing really prepares you for it. ... [view]
May-17-13 - European data plan labelled ‘demented’ » Monday 20 May 2013 by Michael Cross European Commission data protection plans are the biggest threat currently facing the UK economy, a senior Downing Street figure said this week. ... [view]