'Honour killings': murder by any other name - April-30-12
The Guardian - Crime
Gonay Ogmen is the son of a Christian Armenian family in Istanbul. In December 2010, in the back of his car, he gunned down two young people — one of them his sister. His reason for committing a double murder: "honour".
Gonay's 26-year-old sister Sonay had fallen in love with Zekeriya Vural, a Muslim Kurd. The couple had tried to convince their families of their love but, finding no support, had secretly got married. They could have run away but they chose to stay, hoping to eventually get their parents' blessing. Less than two weeks later, Gonay called his sister telling her that the family had decided to approve of their marriage and he would like to take them out for dinner to celebrate. It was a lie.
The case grabbed the headlines in Turkey, a country not unused to so-called honour killings and domestic violence against women. The tragedy acquired an unexpected twist when the press found out that Vural's family were, in fact, of Christian Armenian origin and had converted to Islam more than a generation ago.
Last week, after a long trial, Ogmen was sentenced to two life imprisonments, one for each murder. His lawyers tried to have him acquitted of the charge of "honour killing" on the basis that there were no such examples among the Christian community. The case was followed closely by human rights organisations. It also opened up a whole new debate about the role of culture, rather than religion, in the perpetuation of honour-related incidents.
Violence on the basis of "honour" is spreading at a disturbing rate. The problem is not unique to Turkey or the Middle East. It is happening here, too, in the heart of Britain. According to the Iranian and Kurdish Women's Rights Organisation (IKWRO), more than 2,800 honour-related cases were reported in the UK in 2010. Evidence from police forces reporting suggest an increase of 47% since 2009. Attacks are concentrated in London, the West Midlands and West Yorkshire. Women's organisations argue the real numbers could be four times higher because of the stigma of reporting. For some, such as Hanim Goren, who testified against her husband in 2009, it takes decades to break their silence. Her daughter Tulay, a Turkish Kurd, was only 15 when she was murdered in 1999 in Woodford Green, north London, by her father. Her sin was to fall in love with someone who was twice her age and from another branch of Islam.
Apart from the headlines, we know so little about these cases. While writing my latest novel, Honour, I focused on young men such as Gonay – boys who are taught to believe it is their duty to protect the family honour. I researched cases from Turkey, Germany, Holland, Belgium and Britain, and conversed with Turkish and Kurdish immigrants. I wanted to set the story in London, the multicultural centre of Europe, where there is a relatively better integration, harmony and coexistence than anywhere else today. If it can happen here, it can happen anywhere.
I found it significant that women who are closest to the victims can at times support the decision to kill or remain indifferent to what is taking place, which is tantamount to the same thing. It was also striking to hear a number of mothers say they expected their elder sons to keep an eye on the modesty of their sisters. At the same time, I noticed an enormous pressure on young men and scant tolerance for those who didn't conform. It made me recall Ahmet Yildiz, a Kurdish student who was killed in Istanbul, allegedly by his own father for being openly gay. His story inspired a groundbreaking indie movie called Zenne Dancer.
Both the film and the media coverage helped to increase awareness about the myriad difficulties transgender and gay individuals suffer in patriarchal societies. Any man who does not keep to the ideal definition of masculinity can be ridiculed, bullied or ostracised. The passage from boyhood to manhood is painful and manliness a hard role to play. Without understanding the complexity of the issue and without dealing with the construction of masculinity there is no way we can come close to solving this problem.
Violence against women cuts across all ethnicities, cultures and nationalities of course. Refuge, an organisation that works for women and children fleeing violence, has revealed that, in England and Wales every week, on average two women are murdered by a male who is or was close to them. Gender discrimination seldom materialises in police reports.
Yet there there is something about the concept of "honour crime" that is blurry, if not misleading. For the truth is there is no happiness without freedom and there is no "honour" in murder.
Honour by Elif Shafak is published by Viking, priced £12.99.
Other In the Media General news
In the Media
| December-10-13 - In Focus – Rape: We need an open and honest conversation about rape and sexual offences »
Deputy Assistant Commissioner Martin Hewitt, the national lead for adult sexual offences, says victims must be encouraged to report incidents but also have a right to expect a more honest approach to discussions about the realities of prosecuting rape claims. "We need to be honest about the challenges that are faced in investigating and prosecuting rape," said DAC Hewitt. "Police will do everything they can to ensure that victims get the support they need when reporting a rape or sexual offence." "We will thoroughly investigate the offence and put all our efforts into ensuring justice is done. We want to support those who are victims of these crimes and do all we can to increase reporting levels. "The conviction rate is at an all-time high and this is down to the hard work of police, prosecutors and other agencies working together to develop victim focused approaches and take cases through the courts. But, despite the bravery and tenacity of the victims who do go through the process, a third of rape prosecutions still don't end in a conviction." "That can put people off reporting because they think it isn't worth it. I really want to show people this week that victims should have the confidence to report. It triggers a full investigation into the offence, but also means that victims are able to access medical treatment and support services to help them cope with the experience." In 2012/13, 3,692 rape prosecutions were brought with 63.2 per cent of these cases resulting in convictions; a 5.5 per cent increase from 2008/9. Reporting of sexual offences to the police is also up 9 per cent this year; the largest increase since current recording standards began. The public debate about sex offences, particularly non recent child abuse, may have been responsible for this increase. Jordan Hart, an 18 year old rape survivor whose attacker was jailed for 11 years, has waived her anonymity to support the campaign and encourage more women and men who are victims of rape to report it to the police: "Reporting to the police gave me peace of mind, knowing I hadn't been beaten by him. I was supported by my SOIT officer who gave me advice, guidance, explained what was going to happen and how long it would take; I didn't do anything alone." During the week of 2-6 December, police forces will be running targeted campaigns focussing on communicating how they deal with rape and sexual offences, the support victims should expect and the realities of the judicial process into this type of claim. DAC Hewitt will also be taking to Twitter to answer questions about how the police can better deal with this type of crime directly. The last six years have seen significant improvements in the police response to sexual offences; specialist training of officers, the introduction of early evidence kits, greater access to sexual assault referral centres, and working closely with support groups. DAC Hewitt also called for people to take the debate on prevention of sexual offences seriously: "The debate is far too often restricted to investigation and prosecution; I am very keen that we do all we can to tackle rape and that means generating a challenging debate about prevention as well. Most rape involves the coming together of some form of power and some type of vulnerability; either permanent or temporary. We need to be using all our powers and tactics to understand how this happens, to mitigate the vulnerability and reduce the opportunities for that power to be abused. I am keen to talk about how this can be done." To report a sexual offence or rape to the police, call 101 or 999 in an emergency. ... [view]
| December-10-13 - On Human Rights Day, I'll be thinking of my father in a Chinese prison | Ti-Anna Wang »
Today is Human Rights Day, an occasion commemorating the United Nations' passage of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in 1948. The standards established that day built upon universal freedoms proclaimed by the allied forces during the second world war. In the aftermath of that horrific war, they were intended to deter systematic human rights violations, and to raise awareness and action when they do occur. ... [view]
| December-10-13 - The fight for human rights in Britain must be renewed | Nicolas Bratza »
Human Rights Day is a time for reflection on the achievements and failures in the defence of rights and freedoms. It is for me also a time of disappointment. Disappointment that the human rights debate in the UK has become so polarised and that the untold benefits which have flowed from being a party to the European convention on human rights have been lost in the clamour against the convention system, which the UK played such a leading role in creating. ... [view]
| December-10-13 - Lib Dem ex-minister calls for new spy laws »
A former Liberal Democrat minister is to demand new laws to make sure Britain's spying agencies can never intercept calls or email data without a specific warrant, arguing that Edward Snowden's revelations have exposed inadequate judicial oversight of surveillance powers. ... [view]
| December-09-13 - Jailed book dealer who handled stolen Shakespeare folio found dead in prison »
A flamboyant book dealer jailed for handling a stolen edition of Shakespeare's first folio took his own life in prison, an inquest heard. Raymond Scott, from Wingate, County Durham, was serving an eight-year sentence when he was found dead in his cell by prison officers. The inquest at Berwick magistrates' court heard that he had severe wounds to his neck and was discovered with razorblades in his hand. ... [view]
| December-09-13 - Gaps in our borders remain unplugged »
More than 10 years ago, the Labour government was warned that hundreds of small airports and ports were the “soft underbelly” of Britain’s counter-terrorism efforts. A report from Lord Carlile QC into their effectiveness stated: “The risk of lethal material entering the UK on a light aircraft landing at a busy general aviation airport or remote rural airstrip is real.” In 2006, these concerns were raised again. Ministers were told that at some smaller airfields, customs and immigration officers were rarely seen. ... [view]
| December-08-13 - We must not apply civilian law to the battlefield »
The Sunday Telegraph can disclose that a human rights ruling by the courts has left British troops facing 11 separate inquiries about their conduct in Iraq. We all want to see justice done for anyone who has suffered as a result of abuses conducted in the fog of war, and it is right that battlefield discipline be maintained and claims investigated. But it is troubling to see law designed to cover civilian life being applied to the special, and uniquely stressful, circumstances of the battlefield. ... [view]
| December-07-13 - After Marine A, some harsh truths »
Sergeant Alexander Blackman, "Marine A", 6ft 3in tall and ramrod straight, after being sentenced to life imprisonment, reduction to the ranks and dismissal with disgrace from Her Majesty's Service, marched out of the courtroom and from what has been his two-rows-of-medals life these past 15 years like a true Royal Marines NCO. Here was the self-discipline and professionalism that had eluded him in that moment in Helmand when, in cold blood, he shot a wounded Taliban insurgent. A man is more than his worst mistake. ... [view]
| December-06-13 - Seventh man jailed over 'honour killing' of Banaz Mahmod »
A seventh man has been jailed in connection with the murder of Banaz Mahmod, 20, who was strangled in January 2006 and her body stored in a suitcase before being driven out of London towards Birmingham, where she was intended to be hidden in a shallow grave. Dana Amin, 33, was convicted at Southwark crown court of perverting the course of justice and preventing the victim's lawful and decent burial, and was jailed for eight years. ... [view]